No products
-
Blossom
Hair: Soft and Uncut Eyes: Perfect Symbol: Perfect Other: Has some purple staining on the tip of one ear.
$10.00In Stock -
Island Rainbow
Hair: Soft and uncut Eyes: Perfect Cutie Mark: Some minor scuffs Other: Highlighter name written on non-display side.
$6.00In Stock -
Tokidoki My Melody
Description: Tokidoki x Hello Kitty Series 3 Blind Bag (Cherry Blossoms) My Melody character. My Melody is in excellent shape with very few paint rubs and no discoloration.
$20.00In Stock -
Super Long Hair Pony Cleaning
Surface cleaning, hair washed. Does not include detailing around symbols/cutie marks
$15.00In Stock -
-
-
Sweetie Belle
This version of Sweetie Belle was supposed to have a wig, but it has been lost over the years.
$2.00In Stock -
Charm - Strawberry Swirl
Other: Clear charm came as a bonus with Strawberry Swirl. Charm is slightly more yellow than Sunny Daze IIs.
$10.00In Stock
-
Unicorn Sinner Sticker
Proudly proclaim your allegiance with the devil by displaying this holographic unicorn sticker! Measures 3" x 3" and is holographic. THIS IS A PRE-ORDER. Stickers will ship no later than 6/1/2026
$5.00In Stock -
Baby Bottle- Pink
This pink and white baby bottle was included with: Baby Firefly, Baby Cotton Candy, Baby Lickity Split, Baby Lofty, Bootsy/Tootsie. Baby Gusty is for size comparison only and is not included.
$1.00In Stock -
-
Baby Bottle- Yellow
This yellow and white baby bottle was included with: Baby Cotton Candy, Baby Gusty, Baby Shady, or Lullaby Nursery. Baby Gusty is for size comparison only and is not included.
$1.00In Stock -
Baby Bottle- White
This smaller version of the pony baby bottle came with the newborn twins. Baby Gusty is for size comparison only and is not included.
$4.00In Stock -
Diaper
Baby Pony Diapers came with numerous baby ponies, including the first set, beddy bye eyes, newborns, newborn twins, and the Lullaby Nursery.
$1.00In Stock -
Sweetie Belle
This version of Sweetie Belle was released in 2008 and came with the Sweet Sundae Amusement Park or Deliver Goodies.
$5.00In Stock -
-
-
-
We Ship Worldwide
Sorry, shipments cannot be made to Equestria, Narnia, Middle Earth, or Italy. Mars is a maybe.
-
Customer Service
Questions? We've got answers.
-
Secure Payment
All payments are processed through with Comodo SSL, ensuring even Tirek couldn't pry your information from the ether.
The New Gray Mare
This store is only a portion of the much larger New Gray Mare website. Don't be afraid to jump over to the other side of this marvelous site and explore:
Upcoming Events - 2022
March
- 20th Columbus Toy Show - https://www.ctspromotions.com/
- 26th Great Ohio Toy Show -https://www.facebook.com/ohiotoys/
April
- 8th Friendship Flea - https://www.friendshipflea.com/
- 9th Queen City Doll Show - https://www.facebook.com/Queen-City-Beautiful-Doll-Club-Show-Sale-110938920472088/
May
- 13th Friendship Flea - https://www.friendshipflea.com/
June
- 10th Friendship Flea - https://www.friendshipflea.com/
- 25-26th My Little Pony Fair - https://www.mylittleponycon.com/
July
- 15th-17th TrotCon - https://trotcon.net/
August
- 28th Columbus Toy Show - https://www.ctspromotions.com/