Store

Beachberry- TRU Exclusive
Beachberry- TRU Exclusive
$8.00
Big Macintosh
Big Macintosh
$15.00
Coconut Cream- TRU Exclusive
Coconut Cream- TRU Exclusive
$8.00
Wave 1 Card- Applejack
Wave 1 Card- Applejack
$5.00
Wave 1 Card- Fluttershy
Wave 1 Card- Fluttershy
$5.00
Wave 1 Card- Pinkie Pie
Wave 1 Card- Pinkie Pie
$5.00
Wave 1 Card- Rainbow Dash
Wave 1 Card- Rainbow Dash
$5.00
Wave 1 Card- Rarity
Wave 1 Card- Rarity
$5.00
Wave 1 Card- Twilight Sparkle
Wave 1 Card- Twilight Sparkle
$5.00
Wave 1- Applejack #2
Wave 1- Applejack #2
$5
Wave 1- Bumblesweet #10
Wave 1- Bumblesweet #10
$5.00
Wave 1- Cherry Spices #17
Wave 1- Cherry Spices #17
$5.00
Wave 1- Firecracker Burst #21
Wave 1- Firecracker Burst #21
$5.00
Wave 1- Fizzy Pop #11
Wave 1- Fizzy Pop #11
$5.00
Wave 1- Flower Wishes #12
Wave 1- Flower Wishes #12
$5.00
Wave 1- Fluttershy #6
Wave 1- Fluttershy #6
$5.00
Wave 1- Lemon Hearts #16
Wave 1- Lemon Hearts #16
$5.00
Wave 1- Lily Blossom #8
Wave 1- Lily Blossom #8
$5.00
Wave 1- Lucky Swirl #19
Wave 1- Lucky Swirl #19
$5.00
Wave 1- Pinkie Pie (Glitter) #22
Wave 1- Pinkie Pie (Glitter) #22
$15.00
Wave 1- Rainbow Dash (Glitter) #24
Wave 1- Rainbow Dash (Glitter) #24
$15.00
Wave 1- Roseluck
Wave 1- Roseluck
$5.00
Wave 1- Sugar Grape #7
Wave 1- Sugar Grape #7
$5.00
Wave 1- Sweetcream Scoops #20
Wave 1- Sweetcream Scoops #20
$5.00
Wave 1- Sweetie Blue #14
Wave 1- Sweetie Blue #14
$5.00
Wave 1- Sweetie Swirl #18
Wave 1- Sweetie Swirl #18
$5.00
Wave 1- Twilight Sparkle (Glitter) #23
Wave 1- Twilight Sparkle (Glitter) #23
$15.00
Wave 11- Big Wig (AF) #6
Wave 11- Big Wig (AF) #6
$7.00
Wave 11- Cheese Sandwich (AN) #13
Wave 11- Cheese Sandwich (AN) #13
$20.00
Wave 11- Cloudia Breezie (AX) #22
Wave 11- Cloudia Breezie (AX) #22
$10.00
Wave 11- Flash Sentry (AE) #5
Wave 11- Flash Sentry (AE) #5
$10.00
Wave 11- Lilac Breezie (AZ) #24
Wave 11- Lilac Breezie (AZ) #24
$8.00
Wave 11- Neon Lights (AL) #11
Wave 11- Neon Lights (AL) #11
$7.00
Wave 11- Purple Wave (AI) #9
Wave 11- Purple Wave (AI) #9
$7.00
Wave 11- Spitfire (AK) #10
Wave 11- Spitfire (AK) #10
$10.00
Wave 11- Sunny Breezie (AY) #23
Wave 11- Sunny Breezie (AY) #23
$10.00
Wave 2- Rainbow Flash  #18
Wave 2- Rainbow Flash #18
$25
Wave 3 Card- Apple Dazzle
Wave 3 Card- Apple Dazzle
$5.00
Wave 3 Card- Golden Grape
Wave 3 Card- Golden Grape
$5.00
Wave 3- Applejack (41592) #19
Wave 3- Applejack (41592) #19
$8.00
Wave 3- Berry Shine (41562) # 16
Wave 3- Berry Shine (41562) # 16
$10.00
Wave 3- Glow Pinkie Pie (40562) #06
Wave 3- Glow Pinkie Pie (40562) #06
$25.00
Wave 3- Glow Twilight Sparkle (41522) #12
Wave 3- Glow Twilight Sparkle (41522) #12
$25.00
Wave 3- Lovestruck (loose)
Wave 3- Lovestruck (loose)
$6.00
Wave 3- Pinkie Pie (41532) #13
Wave 3- Pinkie Pie (41532) #13
$8.00
Wave 3- Rainbowshine (40542) #04
Wave 3- Rainbowshine (40542) #04
$12.00
Wave 4- Applejack (80216) #1
Wave 4- Applejack (80216) #1
$10.00
Wave 4- Applejack (Metallic 81286) $18
Wave 4- Applejack (Metallic 81286) $18
$10.00
Wave 4- Chance-A-Lot (81206) #10
Wave 4- Chance-A-Lot (81206) #10
$5.00
Wave 4- Electric Sky (80296) #9
Wave 4- Electric Sky (80296) #9
$8.00
Wave 4- Mosely Orange (82206) #20
Wave 4- Mosely Orange (82206) #20
$7.00
Wave 4- Royal Riff (80266) #6
Wave 4- Royal Riff (80266) #6
$7.00
Wave 4- Twilight Sky (81276) #17
Wave 4- Twilight Sky (81276) #17
$5.00
Wave 4- Twilight Velvet (82236) #22
Wave 4- Twilight Velvet (82236) #22
$10.00
Wave 5- Flippity Flop
Wave 5- Flippity Flop
$8.00
Wave 5- Ribbon Wishes
Wave 5- Ribbon Wishes
$6.00
Wave 5- Twilight Velvet
Wave 5- Twilight Velvet
$20.00
Wave 7- Apple Stars (92206) #20
Wave 7- Apple Stars (92206) #20
$8.00
Wave 7- Applejack (90266) #6
Wave 7- Applejack (90266) #6
$5.00
Wave 7- Banana Bliss (91236) #13
Wave 7- Banana Bliss (91236) #13
$7.00
Wave 7- Banana Fluff (90296) #9
Wave 7- Banana Fluff (90296) #9
$7.00
Wave 7- Barber Groomsby (92216) #21
Wave 7- Barber Groomsby (92216) #21
$7.99
Wave 7- Berry Dreams (91266) #16
Wave 7- Berry Dreams (91266) #16
$7.00
Wave 7- Caramel Apple (92226) #22
Wave 7- Caramel Apple (92226) #22
$7.00
Wave 7- Cherry Pie (90276) #7
Wave 7- Cherry Pie (90276) #7
$7.00
Wave 7- Fluttershy (90226) #2
Wave 7- Fluttershy (90226) #2
$5.00
Wave 7- Holly Dash (91256) #15
Wave 7- Holly Dash (91256) #15
$15.00
Wave 7- Holly Dash (Loose)
Wave 7- Holly Dash (Loose)
$5.00
Wave 7- Lilac Links (91206) #10
Wave 7- Lilac Links (91206) #10
$7.00
Wave 7- Lily Blossom (91296) #19
Wave 7- Lily Blossom (91296) #19
$7.00
Wave 7- Lily Valley (92246) #24
Wave 7- Lily Valley (92246) #24
$7.00
Wave 7- Misty Fly (91226) #12
Wave 7- Misty Fly (91226) #12
$10.00
Wave 7- Pinkie Pie (90216) #1
Wave 7- Pinkie Pie (90216) #1
$5.00
Wave 7- Rainbow Dash (90246) #4
Wave 7- Rainbow Dash (90246) #4
$5.00
Wave 7- Soarin/Spitfire (91276) #17
Wave 7- Soarin/Spitfire (91276) #17
$15.00
Wave 7- Spitfire/Soarin (92236) #23
Wave 7- Spitfire/Soarin (92236) #23
$15.00
Wave 8- Comet Tail (AR) #16
Wave 8- Comet Tail (AR) #16
$5.00
Wave 8- Flam (AF)  #06
Wave 8- Flam (AF) #06
$6.00
Wave 8- Flim Skim (AG) #07
Wave 8- Flim Skim (AG) #07
$6.00

 



Store Categories

Expand All | Shrink All
IMPORTANT: Please note, any item made before 2008 has not been tested for lead or phthalates and should be kept out of the reach of children. Items sold at The New Gray Mare are intended as collectibles.